The National Trial Lawyers
Expertise 2020
Expertise 2016
Avvo Rating
Avvo
Avvo
Avvo

Technically “Possessing” a Drug Isn’t an Automatic Conviction

Technically “Possessing” a Drug Isn’t an Automatic ConvictionA common problem with drug possession cases these days involves the situation whereby drugs are found with several people around, i.e. “constructive possession”. How do Orlando police decide who to charge with possession? Such situations require actual, good ‘ol fashioned police work, the kind of stuff Orlando defense attorney’s such as myself are not used to seeing. While that can be good for business, we all suffer when government employees (police) do not do their job.

So, to get back on track here, drugs found in the presence of several people requires that the state prove the person charge had (1) dominion and control, plus (2) knowledge of the contraband’s presence. Today, we’re focusing on one of my favorite dominion and control cases, Roberts v. State, 505 So.2d 547 (Fla. 3rd DCA 1987). In Roberts, the two co-defendants Solie and Roberts were unknowingly brokering the sale of 108 pounds of weed with undercover agents. Before consumating the deal, the defendant’s wanted to weigh the bales first, so the undercover agents showed up with bales of weed. Roberts took possession of a bail of cannabis on which a sale was not yet completed to weigh it, but before he could do so take-down units rushed into the home and arrested Roberts with felony possession (among other things).

With regard to the felony possession of cannabis, the appeals court overturned Roberts’ conviction. Even though Roberts, technically, had ‘control’ over the weed, the court found that he did not have ‘dominion’ over the bail, as the bale was still owned by the undercover agents. The court held that “Under these circumstances, neither Solie’s transitory touching of the bale nor the bale’s presence in the house is sufficient to demonstrate that either Solie or Roberts possessed it, either actually or constructively.” Id.

Once again, technically “possessing” a drug does not mean that a person is actually guilty of the criminal act of possession. When multiple people are present (i.e. constructive possession), the law requires both “dominion and control” of the drug. If you have any doubts, there’s a great criminal defense attorney in Orlando that can discuss such matters with you, give him a call….

Client Reviews
★★★★★
"If you need legal help your in the right place John Guidry is efficient professional and gets the job done. There’s no games or gimmicks. John will always be highly recommended by me . Thank you John for all of your help.” Jovon W.
★★★★★
"Straightforward and will go the extra mile for you. If the unfortunate need ever arises, John would always be my first call. Honesty and integrity are the words that come to mind in reference to his impeccable service. Thankful for you, John.” Renee F.
★★★★★
"If you need an excellent lawyer I would recommend the Law Firm of John Guidry 100%. He took the time to hear me out and helped me with my case. Thank you so much John.” Edwin M.